Fixed price or cost-plus contract?

Proptez· 1 views

Our builder offered either a fixed-price contract or cost-plus. What's the difference, and which one protects us better?

2 Answers

Fixed price (lump sum): the builder agrees to deliver the defined scope for a set price. Variations change the price, but you know the base cost up front.

  • Best when plans and specifications are complete
  • Gives budget certainty
  • Watch for provisional sums and PC allowances, which can still move

Cost-plus: you pay the actual cost of labour and materials, plus the builder's margin (a percentage or fixed fee).

  • Suits jobs with genuine unknowns: major restorations, heritage work, insurance repairs
  • You see every cost, and can save if things go smoothly
  • Risk sits with you: if it takes longer or costs more, you pay

Several states restrict cost-plus contracts for residential work to particular situations, and require an estimate and written explanation. Check your state's rules.

For most homeowners, a fixed-price contract based on complete plans gives better protection. If you do go cost-plus, ask for a detailed estimate, regular cost reports, the margin in writing, and approval rights for large purchases.

0
Gagan Kohli

We went fixed price for our renovation. The extra time spent finalising every selection before signing paid off: only two small variations in the whole job.

0